Mechanical vs Membrane: Which is the Best Gaming Keypad for You?

A gaming keypad is a device that provides gamers with an extra set of keys, usually located in the left side of the keyboard. Gaming keypads are designed to provide gamers with more control while they play and can be used for different types of games such as first-person shooters, role playing games, and real time strategy games.

We are supported by our audience. When you purchase through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission, at no extra cost for you. Learn more. Last update on 8th December 2023 / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API.

There are two main types of gaming keypads: mechanical and membrane.

Pros and Cons of Mechanical Keypads

Pros: Mechanical keypads are incredibly durable and have a longer lifespan than membrane keypads. They also provide greater tactile feedback, making them more comfortable to use for long gaming sessions.

There is also the added benefit of being able to customize mechanical keypads with different switch types, backlighting options, and other features that make it easier to personalize your setup. Finally, they have faster response time compared to membrane keypads which can be beneficial when playing fast-paced games.

Cons: The main disadvantage of using a mechanical keypad is that they tend to be much more expensive than their membrane counterparts. Additionally, they are much louder due to the clicky sound produced by the keys when typing or gaming.

Pros and Cons of Membrane Keypads

PROS: Membrane keypads are generally much cheaper than mechanical ones, making them a great option for gamers on a budget. They also tend to be quieter when typing due to their rubber dome switches, which can be beneficial in certain environments.

Additionally, membrane keypads are less prone to spills or accidents since they use rubber domes instead of metal contacts like mechanical keyboards do.

CONS: Unfortunately, the trade-off is that membrane keypads tend to be less durable than their mechanical counterparts and provide less tactile feedback while gaming; this can make it more difficult to feel when each button press has been registered correctly. Furthermore, there is typically limited customization options with membrane keypads as compared to mechanical ones; this includes being able to adjust the actuation point and response time of each switch.

Finally, because of the rubber dome design used by many types of membrane keyboards, input lag tends to be an issue with them; this means that inputs may not register as quickly as they would on a faster responding keyboard such as one using mechanical switches.

Factors to Consider When Choosing a Gaming Keypad

Your budget will determine which type of gaming keypad you can afford and what features come with that particular option.

Another factor to consider is the type of games that you play. Different genres require different levels of response time, for example FPS games require fast reflexes and thus need a keyboard with low latency keys.

Additionally, personal preferences should be taken into account such as tactile feedback from the keys (do you prefer soft or hard presses? ), noise level (how much do you want your key presses to stand out?) and customization options (would you like your gaming keypad to have backlighting?).

Depending on all these factors, one can decide which type of gaming keypad would best suit their individual needs.

Comparison of Leading Brands of Mechanical and Membrane Keypads

Razer BlackWidow is a mechanical gaming keypad that features tactile feedback, allowing gamers to feel each key press. It also has an ergonomic design and adjustable backlighting for maximum comfort and visibility in any lighting condition.

The Logitech G810 is another popular mechanical gaming keypad with customizable RGB lighting, 26-key rollover, and ultra-fast response times. SteelSeries Apex M750 is another highly rated mechanical gaming keypad with programmable macro keys and durable aluminum construction for ultimate performance and durability.

For those looking for a more affordable option, the Logitech G213 membrane gaming keyboard offers great value with its spill resistant design and responsive keys. Razer Ornata takes things up a notch with its hybrid mecha-membrane switches providing both comfort of a membrane switch along with the speed of a mechanical one!

Finally, HyperX Alloy FPS provides gamers on budget an entry level solution offering reliable performance at an affordable price point thanks to its solid steel frame construction ensuring years of quality use!

Final Thoughts

Ultimately, the best gaming keypad for you will depend on your personal needs and preferences. It is important to consider the pros and cons of both mechanical and membrane keypads, as well as any specific factors that are most important to you – such as comfort, responsiveness or price point.

Make sure to do your research into what type of gaming experience each keypad can offer, so that you can make an educated decision when deciding which one is right for you. Don’t forget to try out different types of keyboards in person if possible; this way you can get a feel for the keyboard before committing to purchasing it!