The Differences Between Cherry MX and Gateron Switches
Mechanical keyboards have taken the world by storm with their tactile feedback and satisfying sound. The switches used in these keyboards play a crucial role in determining the overall experience of typing or gaming. Cherry MX and Gateron are two of the most popular switch manufacturers in the market, each with its own unique characteristics.
Understanding the differences between Cherry MX and Gateron switches can help users choose the right switch for their needs. Cherry MX switches are widely considered as the gold standard in mechanical keyboard switches. They were first introduced by Cherry Corporation in 1983 and have since become synonymous with high-quality mechanical keyboards. Cherry MX switches come in various colors that indicate different actuation forces, tactile feedback, and noise levels.
On the other hand, Gateron switches are relatively new to the game but have gained a significant following among enthusiasts due to their smoothness and affordability. Gateron switches also offer a range of colors, each with its own unique characteristics that cater to different users’ preferences. In this article, we will explore the differences between Cherry MX and Gateron switches and help you choose which one is best suited for your needs.
History Of Cherry Mx And Gateron Switches
Cherry MX and Gateron switches are two of the most popular mechanical keyboard switches available in the market today.
Cherry MX switches were first introduced in 1983 by Cherry Corporation, a German company that specializes in computer input devices. They quickly became popular among gamers and typists alike due to their tactile feedback and durability.
Gateron switches, on the other hand, are relatively new to the market, having been introduced in 2014 by a Chinese company called Huizhou Gateron Electronic Technology Co., Ltd.
Both Cherry MX and Gateron switches have their own unique characteristics that set them apart from each other. Cherry MX switches are known for their consistency and high-quality construction. They come in a variety of colors (Black, Red, Brown, Blue, Clear, Green) each with its own characteristic feel and sound.
Gateron switches are often compared to Cherry MX switches due to their similar design and feel. However, they are generally considered smoother than Cherry MX switches due to their use of different materials during the manufacturing process.
Overall, both types of switches have their own strengths and weaknesses which make them suitable for different purposes depending on individual preferences.
Actuation Force And Tactile Feedback
Actuation force and tactile feedback are essential considerations when choosing between Cherry MX and Gateron switches.
Actuation force refers to the amount of pressure required to register a keystroke, while tactile feedback describes the sensation felt by the user when pressing a key.
Cherry MX switches are known for their high actuation force, making them popular among gamers who require quick and precise keystrokes. The actuation force for most Cherry MX switches ranges from 45g to 60g, with some models requiring up to 80g of force.
In terms of tactile feedback, Cherry MX switches have a distinct bump that can be felt when pressing down on a key, providing users with added confirmation that their keystroke has been registered. However, some users may find the bump too pronounced, leading to fatigue during extended typing sessions.
On the other hand, Gateron switches have a lower actuation force compared to Cherry MX switches, making them easier to press down on and more comfortable for prolonged use. The actuation force for most Gateron switches ranges from 35g to 50g, with some models requiring up to 80g of force.
In terms of tactile feedback, Gateron switches have a smoother bump compared to Cherry MX switches, which some users may prefer as it provides a more subtle indication that a keystroke has been registered.
Overall, the choice between Cherry MX and Gateron switches will depend on individual preferences in terms of actuation force and tactile feedback.
Noise Level And Smoothness
When it comes to choosing a mechanical keyboard, noise level and smoothness are two crucial factors that must be taken into consideration. Both Cherry MX and Gateron switches offer different levels of noise and smoothness, which can significantly impact the user’s typing experience.
The noise level of a switch is measured in decibels (dB), with higher dB indicating louder switches. Cherry MX switches are known for their relatively high noise level, making them less suitable for office or public use. On the other hand, Gateron switches have a lower noise level, making them more favorable for those who prefer quieter typing.
In terms of smoothness, both Cherry MX and Gateron switches perform well, but some variations within each brand may differ in their overall feel. Here are four key points to consider regarding noise level and smoothness when comparing Cherry MX and Gateron switches:
- Cherry MX switches have a higher actuation force than Gateron switches.
- Gateron switches provide smoother keystrokes due to their thinner stem pins.
- Both Cherry MX and Gateron switches offer different levels of tactile feedback.
- The sound produced by each switch can vary depending on the keyboard’s construction and design.
Overall, whether you prefer a loud or quiet typing experience depends on your personal preference. However, if you prioritize smoothness over noise level or vice versa, it is essential to consider how each switch performs in these areas before making a final decision.
Cost And Availability
As discussed in the previous section, noise level and smoothness are important considerations when choosing between Cherry MX and Gateron switches. However, another factor to consider is the cost and availability of these switches.
When it comes to cost, Gateron switches are generally more affordable than Cherry MX switches. This is because Gateron is a newer brand that is still establishing itself in the market, while Cherry MX has been around for decades and has a well-established reputation. Additionally, Cherry MX switches are produced in Germany, which can drive up the cost due to labor and production expenses.
In terms of availability, both Cherry MX and Gateron switches are widely available online. However, depending on your location and preferred switch type, one may be easier to find than the other. For example, if you live in Europe or Asia, Cherry MX switches may be more readily available since they are produced in Germany. On the other hand, if you prefer certain types of Gateron switches that are not as popular as others (such as low-profile or silent variants), they may be harder to find compared to their Cherry MX counterparts.
| Switch Type | Actuation Force | Lifespan |
|---|---|---|
| Cherry MX Red | 45g | 50 million keystrokes |
| Gateron Red | 45g | 50 million keystrokes |
| Cherry MX Brown | 55g | 50 million keystrokes |
| Gateron Brown | 45g/55g/60g (depending on version) | 50 million keystrokes |
| Cherry MX Blue | 60g | 50 million keystrokes |
| Gateron Blue | 55g/60g (depending on version) | 50 million keystrokes |
Overall, when deciding between Cherry MX and Gateron switches, it’s important to take into account both noise level/smoothness and cost/availability. While Cherry MX switches may have a more established reputation, Gateron switches can offer a more affordable option with similar performance. Additionally, availability may vary depending on your location and preferred switch type, so it’s important to do your research before making a decision.
Choosing The Right Switch For You
Choosing the Right Switch for You:
When it comes to choosing between Cherry MX and Gateron switches, there are a few factors to consider. Firstly, it is worth noting that both switches are mechanical, meaning they use a physical switch rather than a rubber dome to register keystrokes. However, there are differences in the quality and feel of each switch.
One factor to consider is the actuation force required for each switch. Cherry MX switches have a higher actuation force than Gateron switches, which means they require more pressure to activate. This can be beneficial for those who prefer a tactile feedback when typing, as it provides a more satisfying feel when keys are pressed. On the other hand, Gateron switches have a lower actuation force which may be preferred by those who type lightly or quickly. It ultimately comes down to personal preference and typing style.
Other factors such as sound level, durability, and availability of different types of switches should also be taken into consideration.
- Sound level:
- Cherry MX switches tend to be louder due to their design.
- Gateron switches have a smoother mechanism that produces less noise.
- Durability:
- Both Cherry MX and Gateron switches are known for their durability.
- However, some users report that Gateron switches may wear out faster over time compared to Cherry MX switches.
Ultimately, the choice between Cherry MX and Gateron switches will come down to personal preference and individual needs. It is recommended that users try out both types of switches before making a decision as this will provide an accurate representation of how each switch feels while typing. Additionally, researching online reviews from trusted sources can also help inform the decision-making process.
Conclusion
Cherry MX and Gateron switches are two of the most popular mechanical keyboard switches available in the market. While both are used for gaming and typing, they differ in some key aspects such as actuation force, tactile feedback, noise level, smoothness, cost, and availability.
Cherry MX switches were first introduced in 1983 by Cherry Corporation while Gateron switches were developed later in 2000 by Huizhou Gateron Electronic Technology Co. Ltd.
Cherry MX switches have a higher actuation force which makes them more suitable for gamers who need a tactile response while typing. On the other hand, Gateron switches have a lower actuation force which makes them quieter and smoother to use.
Another difference between the two is their noise level. Cherry MX switches produce more audible sounds when pressed compared to Gateron switches making the latter ideal for those who prefer a quieter typing experience.
In terms of cost and availability, Gateron switches are relatively cheaper than Cherry MX switches but may not be as readily available.
An interesting statistic is that according to Keyboard University’s poll of over 10,000 respondents worldwide, the majority preferred Cherry MX Blue (27%) followed closely by Gateron Brown (25%).
The choice ultimately depends on personal preference and intended use whether it be for gaming or typing. Ultimately, it is important to consider all factors before choosing which switch is right for you.